Posted Feb 22, 2007 at 02:55PM by Kristine C. Listed in: Opinions & Analysis Tags: Penny Arcade, Mike Krahulik, Tycho, CNN
Ó

CNN news story about teen sport killings of homeless people... - Image 1Just recently, Penny Arcade's Mike Krahulik (a.k.a., Gabe) has written a scathing commentary in response to a story that was published by CNN. In his commentary, he expresses his dissatisfaction at the fact that, once again, a murder happens and it all gets blamed on the under-aged suspect's gaming habits, and not on other factors which may have shaped the individual into a killer.

For those who don't frequent CNN's site too often, the article in question discusses the recent rise of the number of incidents which involves homeless individuals being murdered by teenagers "for sport."

As a primary example of such an incident, CNN uses the story of the 49-year-old homeless man, Rex Baum, who was killed in 2004 after he was beaten to death by Nathan Moore, Luis Oyola, and Andrew Ihrcke. At the time of the incident, the killers were 15, 16, and 17 years old respectively. After Baum's body was discovered two days after he was killed, the police were able to track down the teens and question them about what they've done. According to police reports, the eldest answered that Baum apparently "reminded him of playing a violent video game."

That statement from Ihrcke may actually be enough to raise more than a few eyebrows within both the gaming and the legislative community. However, what caught Krahulik's attention was the fact that even though the original article continued to present more facts and examples, and also mentions several other theories on what may have been prompting minors to go on killing sprees, it is inevitable that many would stop reading at the point where video games are mentioned. As Krahulik laments:

These kids have given the media their angle and just like all the other cases where games are mentioned no one will ever look any further. No one will ask what their family life was like, what their parents were like, what the kid was like before all this happened. Games did it and that’s the end of the story ... I'm perfectly aware that the reality of the situation was somewhere between the two extremes. I know full well that violent games did not create this killer and I also know that his parents did not make him a murderer ... The sad truth is that the reality we're talking about here would probably never actually see the light of day. The media will tell the story they want to tell regardless and that story will be about violent games. The parents of these kids will be lucky to get two lines in an article about the crime. If they tell a reporter that their son hardly played games or that he was f***ed up long before they bought a Playstation do you really think that will make it into the final article? You'd never see that side of the story, not in a million years. [Bold format not in original text. - QJ]


However, all that has now changed, as the stepmother of one of the suspects (they did not mention which one) has bravely come out in the open to let everyone know the truth about these teens. Who would have known that the parent of a so-called "video game killer" can actually be a gamer herself? Who would have thought that she was a regular Penny Arcade reader? Who would have expected that she would choose to trust the folks of Penny Arcade with the truth instead of handing it over to the mainstream media?

We'll never be as eloquent as Tycho or Gabe, so click on the "Read" link below, read on, and brace yourselves for what a lot of people in politics would probably hate to hear.


Read Permalink  |   Email this  |   Linking Blogs   |   Digg It!

Bookmark / Find this article on:


7 Comments


Sort by:
   by Crater (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » There is no...

There is no read link below... Please edit it with the link for those people who haven't already seen this.

   by Alakahkid (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » None found.

I've braced myself, alas, no read link to be found...

   by Anon (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » URL

http://www.penny-arcade.com/2007/02/21

   by Advertising -
   by Archon (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » Lingering Questions

I hope Gabe did all the requisite legwork to vet this letter. It is already starting to pickup some outside media attention (ironically, the original story was already fading out, video games or no), and if it proves true the changes wrought could be quite surprising. If it turns bogus the backfiring will set us back years in credibility.


   Re: Casey Sillito (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » LEGWORK!?!?!?

You are forgetting that Gabe and Tycho don't consider themselves "journalists". At least that's what Tycho said last week. I'm fine with that as long as they don't do stuff like this. This kind of baseless hysteria is exactly why I stopped reading sites by videogame "journalists" and started reading Penny Arcade exclusively. If they started doing stories like this all the time, I don't know what I'd read.

But what "changes" do you think are going to be "wrought" by this information? He plead guilty and was convicted to 15 years in jail. He's been there for the last 3 YEARS! He apparently never tried to use videogames as a defence. In a 7 minute interview with CNN he mentioned the effects that drugs and alcohol had on him that day a number of times, but he only mentions videogames once. He doesn't even blame them, he just says that the experience reminded him of videogames, which is in keeping with other statements he made about how the experience seemed generally unreal or "like a dream".

THIS STORY IS NOT ABOUT VIDEOGAMES.

Gabe was right about one thing: nobody is going to dig up these facts, because nobody is covering this story because its 3 YEARS OLD!



   Re: Casey Sillito (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » Addendum

I was slightly in error. The 7 minute interview was with Nathan Moore, whereas the comment about videogames was attributed to Moore's friend Andrew Ihrcke.

But this just goes to show how this is not an article about videogames. Pretty much the whole article centres around Moore. If CNN was trying to blame videogames, then why aren't they interviewing the guy who made the videogame comment?

Andrew Ihrcke is, BTW, also went to jail. So his comment about videogames apparently didn't "work" for him either.
   by Goglu666 (Unregistered) - 2007-02-22
 » When murder is the only way to get attention.

Those kid did not wake up one day and told themselves : "Hey let's kill some random guy"

And now media define those murder as "sport killing". A fun way to encourage them. Of course, it doesn't actually encourage them directly, but now it's a fad, and you know how some people like fads.

Anyway, good thing people get their voice out, but still It's not audible in the medias that much for the common public.



Add QJ.NET
Add to My Yahoo!
Google Reader Subscribe with Bloglines
Add  to your Kinja digest Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Add 'www.qj.net' to Newsburst from CNET News.com
Subscribe with SearchFox RSS del.icio.us www.qj.net
Add to Technorati Favorite! Add to My AOL
furl! it Stumble for Treehugger!
User Favorites - November
Most Commented
No commented articles